Apartments for Rent in Sheepshead Bay
Browse recent rentals in Sheepshead Bay, NYC, compare asking prices, and set an alert for the next matching apartment.
Get alerts for new apartments in Sheepshead Bay
We email you new listings that match, on a best-effort basis. You can change the area, size and budget in the next step.
What apartments in Sheepshead Bay rent for
- Studio: $2,200 median, middle 40% $1,900–$2,966 (46 observations)
- 1 bedroom: $2,750 median, middle 40% $2,250–$3,250 (119 observations)
- 2 bedrooms: $3,750 median, middle 40% $2,850–$4,250 (121 observations)
- 3 bedrooms: $3,454 median, middle 40% $3,189–$3,737 (34 observations)
Figures are the final asking rents of apartments that rented in the past two years through September 2026, from RentReboot's neighborhood rent data. They are not signed leases, and observation counts are sample sizes, not the number of apartments available now. See every percentile for Sheepshead Bay.
About the listings on this page
Listings on this page are Sheepshead Bay listings first listed, or first recorded by RentReboot, in the past 15 days, newest first and up to 20 per apartment size, from marketplaces, brokerages and landlord or building websites. Rooms in shared apartments and short-term rentals are not always labeled, and an apartment may already be rented, so confirm the price, lease term and availability with the listing contact before you apply or pay a fee. The interactive view on this page loads them with a map.
Set up apartment alerts to hear about new Sheepshead Bay listings that match your budget, size and neighborhoods.