Average rent in Carroll Gardens
Median asking rents of new listings from the monthly RentReboot NYC Rental Index, then older listing history by apartment size.
The RentReboot NYC Rental Index publishes a neighborhood once it has 50 new listings in a month, and Carroll Gardens had fewer in October 2026. Across Brooklyn, new listings asked a median $3,300 for a studio, $3,650 for a 1-bedroom and $4,195 for a 2-bedroom.
Get alerts for new apartments in Carroll Gardens
We email you new listings that match, on a best-effort basis. You can change the area, size and budget in the next step.
Carroll Gardens listing history, two years to September 2026
These are the final asking rents of apartments that rented in the past two years through September 2026, by bedroom size, with the sample behind every figure. The history stopped updating in September 2026.
| Size | 10th | 30th | Median | 70th | 90th | Sample |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Studio | $2,433 | $2,880 | $3,100 | $3,478 | $5,175 | 32 |
| 1 Bedroom | $3,198 | $3,500 | $4,000 | $4,500 | $5,697 | 287 |
| 2 Bedrooms | $3,850 | $4,900 | $5,500 | $6,230 | $7,500 | 331 |
| 3 Bedrooms | $4,968 | $6,996 | $7,925 | $9,999 | $15,000 | 115 |
| 4 Bedrooms | $9,150 | $10,115 | $11,725 | $15,000 | $16,500 | 30 |
What the Carroll Gardens listing history shows
For 1-bedroom apartments, the 10th-to-90th-percentile spread is $3,198 to $5,697, a difference of $2,499. These are the final asking rents of apartments that rented, which can differ from the signed lease, and the sample size beside each row applies only to that bedroom size.
Across 795 rentals in the neighborhood, published bedroom medians are studio $3,100 (32 rentals); 1-bedroom $4,000 (287 rentals); 2-bedroom $5,500 (331 rentals); 3-bedroom $7,925 (115 rentals); 4-bedroom $11,725 (30 rentals).
How to use this data
Compare an apartment's asking rent with the percentile range for the same bedroom count. A listing below the 30th percentile is inexpensive relative to this sample; one above the 70th percentile is at the higher end. Differences in condition, concessions, exact location, amenities, and listing age can still explain a large price gap.
Use this number to check the income required under NYC's 40x rule, learn how to find rent-stabilized apartments, or decide when to start your search.
RentReboot leaves out bedroom groups with fewer than 5 rentals. Read the rent-data methodology, see the monthly NYC Rental Index, or inspect recent Carroll Gardens listings.
How Carroll Gardens compares: listing history, two years to September 2026
The 1-bedroom median in Carroll Gardens is $4,000 from 287 rentals.
Nearby neighborhoods:
- Gowanus: 1-bedroom median $4,289 from 820 rentals, 0.5 miles away
- Cobble Hill: 1-bedroom median $4,000 from 253 rentals, 0.6 miles away
- Columbia St Waterfront District: 1-bedroom median $3,625 from 38 rentals, 0.6 miles away
Brooklyn overall: 1-bedroom median $3,855 from 18,739 rentals
Every figure is a median final asking rent of apartments that rented in the past two years through September 2026. Distances are straight-line distances between neighborhood centers.
Get Carroll Gardens apartment alerts
Carroll Gardens rent FAQ
What is the average rent in Carroll Gardens?
The RentReboot NYC Rental Index publishes a neighborhood once it has 50 new listings in a month, and Carroll Gardens had fewer in October 2026. Across Brooklyn, new listings asked a median $3,300 for a studio, $3,650 for a 1-bedroom and $4,195 for a 2-bedroom, according to the November 2026 RentReboot NYC Rental Index. These are asking rents, not signed leases.
Get alerted when a new Carroll Gardens apartment is listed →