Average rent in City Island
Asking-rent percentiles by bedroom size, as of October 2026.
The median asking rent for a 2 bedrooms in City Island, NYC is $3,200 as of October 2026, based on 13 observations for that apartment size. The middle of the market extends from about $2,967 at the 30th percentile to $3,550 at the 70th percentile.
| Size | 10th | 30th | Median | 70th | 90th | Sample |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 Bedrooms | $2,900 | $2,967 | $3,200 | $3,550 | $4,000 | 13 |
What the rent range shows
For 2 bedrooms apartments, the 10th-to-90th-percentile spread is $2,900 to $4,000, a difference of $1,100. That range describes current asking prices, not signed lease rents, and the sample size shown beside each row applies only to that bedroom size.
The neighborhood has 21 observations across available bedroom sizes. Only bedroom groups with at least five observations are published; smaller groups are withheld because a handful of listings can produce a misleading median.
How to use this data
Compare an apartment's asking rent with the percentile range for the same bedroom count. A listing below the 30th percentile is inexpensive relative to this sample; one above the 70th percentile is at the higher end. Differences in condition, concessions, exact location, amenities, and listing age can still explain a large price gap.
Use this number to check the income required under NYC's 40x rule, learn how to find rent-stabilized apartments, or decide when to start your search.
RentReboot removes current bedroom groups with fewer than 5 observations from this report. Historical figures are independently labeled and use at most the latest 100 valid observations. Read the rent-data methodology, compare the NYC market summary, or inspect recent City Island listings.